Alan Resnais’ documentary Night and Fog is a hauntingly beautiful portrayal of the horrors of
the Holocaust. Unlike most
documentaries, the image track is much stronger than its soundtrack. The juxtaposition of the modern day color
footage and the black and white stock footage of the concentration camps are powerful
and show the destruction of the remnants of such an unimaginably horrible
place. In the majority of documentaries
the story is told rather than shown but for Night
and Fog, this is not the case. What
the narrator is saying throughout the film is somewhat insignificant in the
grand scheme of the film. He is merely
describing to the audience what we are seeing or what the Nazis for example are
talking about. Nothing more is really
added with the narration and the film arguably would be just as powerful, if
not possibly more, without it. The film’s
score on the other hand has a completely different meaning and purpose to
it. The score seems to contradict the
images the film shows and are at times completely ironic. For example, instead of a somber soundtrack
playing over the images of the dead concentration camp victims the film has an
upbeat, lighthearted, and arguably at times somewhat happy soundtrack. It is in complete contradiction of the viewer’s
own uneasy, and gloomy feelings while watching the film and the purpose of the
film score is probably to provide this complete inner turmoil. The viewer witnesses somber and completely
horrible images but is listening to a soundtrack that gives you a completely
opposite feeling and you are left with a feud of your senses.
While
Night and Fog may not be the norm for film documentaries, the way it was edited
makes it a complete work of art. Between
the juxtaposition of the color modern day footage and the black and white stock
footage, to the film’s happily eerie soundtrack, the documentary becomes
nothing less than completely memorable. Among
the film’s powerful images, what Night
and Fog leaves the viewer with is the most significant. In the end when not one perpetrator of the horrible
actions of the Holocaust claims responsibility it leaves the viewer with the
thought that what happened here can never happen again. For those who do not remember the past are
doomed to repeat it.
Great point regarding the soundtrack's inappropriateness. Although it does often seem playful (contrary to what we see on screen), this contrast does create an uneasiness that is intentional. I agree.
ReplyDelete